Tony Romo: The Jury Is In

Posted by Bryan Martin on July 18, 2009 at 19:03

Do you think Tony Romo is dis­tracted by fame? Maybe you feel like Romo is in his make or break sea­son, or just maybe, you think Romo is far over­rated.  The chances that you can relate to these state­ments is about 90 per­cent.  I say that strictly because where ever you look 9 out of 10 fans are bash­ing Romo's very existence.

Just recently I was rum­mag­ing through DC​.com and read Mick's lat­est arti­cle "Pressure Cooker" and it inspired me to do a lit­tle dig­ging.  You see, Romo's lack of post sea­son pro­duc­tion isn't as fright­en­ing as one might imag­ine.  Though the out­cry of fans would pro­duce a dif­fer­ent story.  I sim­ply decided to com­pare the ever so scru­ti­nized Romo with other NFL greats.  The results were just as I expected, Romo was lead­ing the pack and the fair weather fans argu­ments were proven to be ridiculous.

NAMECOMPATTPCTINTTDRATINGW-​​L RECORDTOTAL YDS
Romo8311,30763.6468194.7281210,562
Montana7131,13063325286.318158,069
Peyton1,3572,22660.98111185.1323216,418
Aikman9201,52860.2605474.6382710,527

Clearly these sta­tis­tics place Romo on com­pa­ra­ble sta­tus with HOF cal­iber Quarterbacks.  So what gives? Why the crit­i­cism? I accredit it to one of two scenario's.  1) The fans of today are too idi­otic to real­ize that foot­ball is a game of growth and matu­rity and not a game of instan­ta­neous suc­cess, and their igno­rance far sur­passes the need to gather infor­ma­tion and sta­tis­tics to help them under­stand the game, or 2) Tony Romo is sim­ply just another vic­tim of Dallas Cowboys Nation.  I can only really offer an expla­na­tion for one, since I can't change the dis­po­si­tion of fans.

The Cowboys micro­scope has been in effect since the 70's when Tom Landry decided to go with Roger Staubach as his starter over Craig Morton.  It then con­tin­ued with Danny White, and claims of Troy Aikman "going soft" before win­ning another Super Bowl in 1995.  This to me says that no mat­ter how tal­ented and skilled a quar­ter­back is, as a Cowboy he is doomed to being faced with the trou­bles of Hollywood. Here is where the prob­lem lies, fans eas­ily for­get or become blind to the tal­ent that truly lies in the quar­ter­back that is lead­ing their team.  Romo has dis­played strong abil­i­ties in arm strength, pass accu­racy, mobil­ity, and throw­ing on the run, which ele­vates him to one of the only true bal­anced quar­ter­backs in the league.

It is my firm opin­ion that if Romo was on a hand­ful of other teams he would be referred to as a gem and most cer­tainly a fran­chise quar­ter­back.  We need to real­ize the facts, we need to open our eyes, and real­ize that Romo is a wor­thy and tal­ented leader for this team.  Facts speak for themselves.

VN:F [1.8.1_1037]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Tony Romo: The Jury Is In5.053
National Football League
  • Bryan - very good points there. I especially like how Romo is not only comparable to the others in stats, but leads just about all of them. I also like how Romo has thrown far less INTs in proportion to TDs than the other three.

    Of course the others had more post season success, and that's what really being judged. He was set as the savior of our dry run in the playoffs, and yet while everyone knows how good he is, we still haven't won a playoff game since 1996.
  • Good article...you are the voice of reason, my man.
  • Bryson, I don't mean to say your wrong, but the post season success for these quarterbacks didn't come fast either. Peyton didn't win a playoff game until after his fouth season, Aikman his third, and Montana won in his third season. This is only relevant because this is actually only Romo's third season as starting quarterback.
  • That's what I was getting at as well. Everyone acts like his first years aren't the same as the first years of the other three QBs because he was pumped up to be the one to finally get it done again.

    Thinking about it, maybe Peyton isn't that great. He is the only one who took that long to win anything in the post season and he had a built and experienced team waiting for him. Romo and Aikman both had young teams that still needed some grooming.
  • I couldn't agree with you more, Peyton's offense was tailor made and the pieces were already in place. You can argue that the same could go for Tom Brady who kind of had everything handed to him. Though his team has changed dramatically since his emergence, Brady had alot of pieces for him to succeed already in place.

    If you wanna argue that, you can compare it to what the Cowboys had in Julius Jones, an old Terry Glenn, and a young team that was in need of some major advancement. Romo's done well with what he's been given.
  • Exactly! And the trip isn't over yet.
  • Austin
    Great article! please dont forget the greatest QB Roger Staubach
    And Romo runs a close second!
    This will be a cowboy year!
  • Joe C
    I sure hope we can win a playoff game this year, i'll be drunk for a month and finally can shove that shit in my friends face, seeing as there skins and giants fans. although I already talk mad shit to the skins ones cuz they haven't done shit either lol
  • Joe I feel you man, I'm from Philly and it's intense i need something to talk about!
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2008-2010 DallasCowboysNation.com.
All Rights Reserved.